City Doughnut portraits
A city or region draws its own Doughnut, a social foundation no one should fall below and an ecological ceiling it should not overshoot, then uses that portrait to set targets and test decisions.
Start small
Run one Doughnut Unrolled workshop with DEAL's free city-portrait tools: 15 to 30 people (council officers, two or three councillors, community groups), mapping local needs and impacts on the four lenses with data that already exists. About 1 to 3 months part-time and roughly AU$2,000 to 10,000 for facilitation and data. Then pilot a Cornwall-style Doughnut impact wheel on 3 to 5 upcoming council reports before any formal adoption.
The problem
Local economic policy is steered by growth indicators that hide residents going without basic needs and the place's ecological overshoot. Councils lack one shared, place-based picture that weighs social and ecological goals together when they decide.
Where it fits
Works best with a council or regional government that has a political champion and a mandate (a climate emergency declaration or recovery plan), good local data on housing, income, health, emissions and materials, a partner who knows the method (DEAL, a university), a civil-society coalition that carries it beyond one election cycle, and a live process to plug it into, such as an official community plan, circular-economy strategy or decision approvals. Thrived in Amsterdam (2020), Brussels-Capital Region (2020), Nanaimo (2020 to 2022), Barcelona (2021) and Cornwall. Needs a modest budget: Brussels spent €311,350 over 2020 to 2024 for a two-person team.
The principle underneath
Showing deprivation and overshoot on one shared picture, scored against the place's own targets and global limits, changes what counts as success from more output to meeting needs within limits. It has the most effect when built into routine decision tools (impact wheels, funding criteria, plan targets) rather than used once as a vision.
A pattern in nature
A healthy organism keeps itself within a living range, enough nutrients without toxic excess, rather than maximising any single quantity.
Who to call
Doughnut Economics Action Lab (free tools and community platform). Amsterdam Doughnut Coalition. Brussels Donut team (Confluences with ICHEC). Cornwall Council's Carbon Neutral Cornwall team (decision wheel). City of Nanaimo planning (Nanaimo Reimagined). Barcelona City Doughnut researchers. Thriving Cities Initiative partners: C40 Cities, Circle Economy, Biomimicry 3.8.
Watch out for
Treating the portrait as branding with no binding targets, which invites greenwashing claims. Measuring nothing. Relying on one councillor. Not explaining the framework, so the name invites ridicule and conspiracy theories. Ignoring big contradictory investments (data centres, airports). A tiny team and staff overload. Data gaps for global impacts. Not linking it to budgets, procurement or planning approvals.
Where it comes from
Created by economist Kate Raworth (Oxfam paper 2012, book Doughnut Economics 2017), built on planetary boundaries science (Rockström, Steffen and colleagues, Stockholm Resilience Centre) and social foundations drawn from the UN Sustainable Development Goals. The city-portrait method was co-developed by DEAL with Biomimicry 3.8, Circle Economy and C40 Cities; the first public city portrait was Amsterdam in April 2020. DEAL shares its tools under open licences and asks users to credit them and stay true to the core concepts; check its current terms before branding a local version.
Where it's worked
Amsterdam, Netherlands · April 2020 to present
First city to formally adopt the Doughnut (8 April 2020). Its city portrait, made with DEAL, C40, Circle Economy and Biomimicry 3.8, underpins the Amsterdam Circular 2020 to 2025 strategy, with targets including halving food waste and cutting consumption by 20% by 2030.
DocumentedSource
Brussels-Capital Region, Belgium · Sept 2020 to 2024+
The Brussels Donut, led by Confluences with ICHEC and DEAL, fed into the Shifting Economy strategy; a 2023 ordinance ties regional business support to social and environmental criteria, with €200 million of regional instruments to go only to firms meeting them by 2030.
DocumentedSource
Nanaimo, British Columbia, Canada · Dec 2020 to 2023+
Council adopted the Doughnut 5 to 4 in December 2020 as a cohesive vision for all city initiatives; it became the basis of Nanaimo Reimagined, the 25-year official community plan adopted in July 2022.
DocumentedSource
Cornwall, UK · c. 2020 to present
Cornwall Council built a Doughnut-based decision-making wheel with 22 segments that lead officers complete for new projects and policies alongside risk assessment; aggregated scores feed the council's carbon inventory.
DocumentedSource
Barcelona, Spain · 2021 to 2025
The municipality, civil servants, academics and consultants co-produced Barcelona's portrait across four lenses with participatory events; a peer-reviewed review in Ecological Economics (2025) draws lessons on linking indicators and everyday politics.
Peer reviewedSource
Global overview (50 local governments) · 2019 to 2024
DEAL reviewed 50 local governments using the Doughnut since 2019, for diagnostics (Brussels, Mexico City, Copenhagen, Grenoble), place-wide strategy (Nanaimo, Ipoh, Glasgow) and impact assessment (Cornwall, Valence Romans, Lviv).
DocumentedSourceDoughnut Economics Action Lab (DEAL) on the Landscape
Where it failed
Amsterdam: a council party (Partij voor de Dieren) accused the city of using the Doughnut to greenwash, citing a council-owned biomass plant, data-centre growth that puts the 2030 climate target out of reach, and much more spending on district heating than on insulating homes; critics called the measures voluntary and unenforceable. Nanaimo: adopted only 5 to 4 in 2020, with the mayor citing staff workload; the 2022 hearing drew mostly opponents with conspiracy fears, a councillor called the plan short on measurable goals, and targets were still pending in 2023. Brussels: a two-person team with little capacity inside government ended up working mainly with businesses rather than shaping administration policy. In general the portrait is often a workshop tool, not binding policy, so it can be shelved without consequence.
Who practises it
Related Fruit
- TreeCommunity currencyA local money, issued and governed by the community, that keeps spending and credit circulating among neighbours and local businesses.
- TreeParticipatory budgetingResidents directly decide how part of a public budget is spent, which moves money toward basic services in poorer areas.
- TreeCitizens' assembly on climateA randomly selected, demographically representative group of residents learns from experts, deliberates and recommends climate policy to decision makers.
- TreeFood policy councilsA standing table of citizens, farmers, food businesses and officials that shapes a city's or region's food policy together.
- SaplingIndependent citizen-run town councils (flatpack democracy)Local people with no party ties stand together on shared ways of working, win the town council and run it openly to deliver practical local action, including on climate.
